Dan Senor
Bringing Clarity to the Fog of War
We mark the 1-year anniversary of the October 7 attacks. Since the outbreak of war in Israel, Dan has reported on the conflict with unmatched depth.
Like so many others, I was horrified by the
events of October 7, 2023, when Hamas launched its gruesome attacks on
civilians in Israel.
The war that has raged for the year since is one of the biggest — and most consequential — news stories of our time. The impacts of the attacks and the war are complex and often confounding. Dan Senor is providing context, analysis and insight at a level no one else matches.
Dan is an author, investor, foreign policy expert, and host of a podcast titled "Call Me Back." Throughout this past year, I've repeatedly turned to Dan and his show to better understand the ongoing conflict between Israel, Hamas, Hezbollah and other Iranian proxies.
Dan's show features some of the most thoughtful conversations you'll find about the war. He has deep connections in Israel, and regularly interviews journalists, officials, and other experts on the ground in Israel and the Middle East.
The story of Israel and its latest conflict is personal for Dan. His mother is
a Holocaust survivor. And he has family members who reside in the country
today.
Outside of his podcast, Dan has written two books about Israel. The first is a well-known work titled Startup Nation, which looks at Israel through a business lens. The book attempts to explain some of the country's tremendous success as an innovator in technology.
More recently, Dan co-authored The Genius of Israel, which examines a seemingly strange dichotomy: Why does this small and constantly threatened country remain one of the happiest and most optimistic countries in the world?
In his writing, Dan explores how things like national service and a sense of
purpose unite the people of Israel. He reveals how these factors and others
seem to help inoculate Israelis to some degree from modern maladies like
depression, drug abuse and suicide.
It's a fascinating book. And to celebrate Dan's appearance on our show, we're
giving away 40 free copies of The Genius of Israel to listeners like
you. Click here to sign up for your chance to win.
Dan's work provides a valuable service to all of us - especially to people like myself, and many other Americans, who have only a general understanding of what's happening in the Middle East.
Whatever your stance is on the wars being waged in and around Israel, I promise you'll be better informed by listening to what Dan has to say.
- Why Dan feels October 7, 2023, was the most important event in Israel in his lifetime (5:35)
- How the conversation about this war inside Israel is more complicated than people realize (22:19)
- Why people throughout Arab nations are tuning in to Dan's show (8:35)
- The 7 fronts Israel is fighting on right now (20:53) What Americans are getting wrong about the war (18:16)
- The source of conflict that isn't getting enough attention (20:32)
- What Israel does differently that helps make their people more resilient (24:26)
- Lessons Dan drew from his mother, who narrowly escaped the Holocaust (36:26)
FRANK BLAKE: So Dan, welcome to Crazy Good Turn podcast.
I gotta start by saying that I've been a faithful listener to your podcast Call
Me Back, particularly since after October 7th.
You've done just an extraordinary job.
And my first question is, I want to ask so immediately after the October 7th
attack, you had a podcast on October 8th, and since then, you've really devoted
the coverage of your podcast to the impacts of the attack and Israel's response
and the larger response in the Middle East and throughout the world.
Why did you make the decision to focus your podcast that way?
DAN SENOR: Well, first of all, thanks Frank for doing this.
I, we, we've known each other for some time, but we've never actually had a
recorded conversation.
FRANK BLAKE: Right.
DAN SENOR: So it's great to do that.
I was focused, the podcast was focused on a number of issues long before
October 7th that included a lot of geopolitics, a lot of focus on the Middle
East, the Russia, Ukraine War, China, China and Taiwan.
We were focused a lot on American politics, the interplay between geopolitics
and American politics.
We were focused on a lot of macroeconomic issues.
And included in all of that was, as I said, the Middle East and Israel.
I would do probably every third or fourth or fifth episode was something
related to Israel.
And then obviously after October 7th, on October
7th, I realized this was the most important event in the life of Israel.
And it, and I think in the life of the diaspora, the Jewish community around
the world, in my lifetime.
I can't think of another moment, in my lifetime, perhaps the fall of the Soviet
Union, which led to hundreds of thousands, millions of Jews from the former
Soviet Union finally being free.
That was, that was a major event.
I can think of the Second Intifada was a major event.
The second Lebanon war was a major, these are major events, but in terms of its
role in the history of the Jewish people and the history of the state of Israel,
there's the October 7th was in a category of its own.
And I realized that that was where my head and heart were and
where my passions were, and I was going to be consuming information and having
conversations with my Israeli friends nonstop from that moment.
And I figured I might as well just record these conversations, and to the
extent that they are almost like an audio journal of what we were all thinking
during that time.
And also a way to use my contacts, my friends, my colleagues in Israel to help
explain to the world the challenges and, and the dilemmas facing Israel as it
dealt with this historic tragically genocidal attack against its country and
the against Israel, and the implications going forward.
And so, I just, it was just intuitive.
My producer Ilan Benatar, who's Israeli, he and I just, it, it was just the two
of us.
And we just said, okay, we gotta pivot.
And we just started, and then we just started doing, I just started calling my
friends in Israel, by the way, the weekend of October 7th, I just started
calling my friends in Israel to say, how you're doing checking in is one, many
people who live abroad from Israel know that's what they were doing on October
7th, is checking in with people.
And one of those people was a gentleman by the name of Haviv Rettig Gur, who
you've probably gotten to -
FRANK BLAKE: Yes. Gotten to know through the podcast. Yeah.
DAN SENOR: He's an amazing guy.
I'm actually seeing him today. I'm having lunch with him today. He's in New
York City.
But he was so powerful. And that was the first conversation I had after October
7th that we posted.
I said to Haviv, we've gotta record this conversation. And we posted it and it
went viral.
And I thought, okay, there's, people want understanding.
People wanna understand nuance.
People want to hear from Israelis. People wanna hear the conversation happening
inside Israel.
And so we just, we just went for it.
FRANK BLAKE: Have your goals for the podcast changed over time?
As you've developed this, you know, as it's gone on sadly far longer than
anybody would've thought.
DAN SENOR: That's a good question.
What I'll tell you what I've learned since, since from the podcast, since
October 7th, which I didn't know at the time.
Because I just didn't spend time thinking about it. I had no reason to, before
October 7th.
One, I've learned that there is extraordinary demand among folks I wouldn't
have expected to understand the conversation - not happening between the
Israeli government and the American people, I mean the Israeli government
blasts out its message and the press here covers it.
Not in American journalists' interpretations of what's happening in Israel.
But there's extraordinary demand for the conversation happening inside Israel,
between Israelis, between Israel.
It's a, it's a vibrant, thriving, messy democracy.
And there's a, there's a rich, often very divisive, very intense conversation
happening among Israelis.
And there's enormous demand for understanding what's going on in that
conversation, because people realize it's much more complicated than one would
think.
FRANK BLAKE: Right.
DAN SENOR: And, and so we've captured a lot of those
conversations.
I didn't know that there would be huge demand for that, but there is, A.
B - what I also didn't know is there's extraordinary demand for history, for
getting educated.
I've been blown away by this, frankly.
Like, I, you know, I am been involved with Israel for a number of years.
My really, my entire, from college days
on, even younger, I've written, I've co-authored two books about Israel. I've
spent a lot of time on Israel.
I kind of took for granted that the resources that were out there that help
explain Israel's history, tell its story, were updated and modernized.
And what I realized after October 7th is they're not. That, that the degree to
which there's a demand for education, was surprising to me.
I just didn't realize the resources had become outdated.
I mean, just to give you a sense, the episodes.
So we do no planning about what we're trying to achieve with an episode.
We, we, we just, it's sort of like what's interesting to us. We record and we
sort of look - probably what you do.
It's what's interesting to us. And then we record it and post it.
So I'm very interested in history. I'm very interested in how we got here.
So I have a lot of dense, which someone could argue boring and, and heavy
episodes, very wonky episodes about the history of UNRRA, the history of the
two state solution, the history of I mean, I can go on and on and on.
The origins of the '48 War of Independence, those episodes, which are long, and
I would say boring, but interesting to me, are some of our highest performing
episodes.
FRANK BLAKE: So people want, and I've just gotta say, as a
listener and not Jewish, and not having deep knowledge of Israel beforehand,
not boring in the slightest.
DAN SENOR: Okay, good. Well, I didn't know that.
I didn't know that.
FRANK BLAKE: You are your version of "Fauda" on a podcast. I, you sort
of get the complexity of this, and it's, it's riveting.
DAN SENOR: So, so I think so I didn't, I didn't expect that, like
how much demand there is for history.
People wanna get educated.
And then the last thing I would say is, I have been surprised, I gotta be
careful how I say this, but, but my politics, at least in the U.S. and as it
relates to us, foreign policy tend to be right of center.
And what I have been struck by is how much of our audience is left of center.
And meaning, I think there are a lot of people who live outside of Israel,
particularly Jews whose politics are generally left of center, but they feel
like they don't have a home now because they're not allowed to in many of their
political or, or ideological communities oriented communities.
They're, being a Zionist is not welcome.
That's like, they can't, those communities don't let people reconcile being a,
a liberal and being, and being pro-Israel.
And they found, they have found, at least on my podcast, some of my guests are
just that.
So take someone like Scott Galloway, who is a very proud, unapologetic liberal,
and is a very angry Zionist because he thinks the Jews in Israel are being held
to a standard that no other people are, are whatever be expected to be held to.
FRANK BLAKE: A great, he has a great example of what would happen
if it happened in the United States, the equivalent, right.
Which is something like somebody coming in and taking an entire class at Baylor
University back to, you know?
DAN SENOR: Right, exactly. Kidnapping them. Exactly.
And so, and putting them in a tunnel somewhere in the, in Mexico, that's what
he says, hiding them in Mexico.
And so, and so when someone like him, Scott, comes on, and it's not just Scott,
but he's an example, I just think there's a lot of liberals who gravitate to
the podcast, otherwise wouldn't.
So it's more like what I'm surprised by what I've learned.
And, I, my view is I'm just gonna keep doing what I'm doing.
The one thing I think we're gonna do more of, I guess one goal that like has,
has now become a goal of ours, which I just didn't think of as a goal at first,
is we're gonna be much more deliberate now about these history-focused
episodes, because we just think there's a vacuum out there and we want to fill
it. FRANK BLAKE: Well, I would encourage all our listeners to go back through
your episodes because they are fascinating and just incredible learning, and
incredibly important.
I have a, this is a modest question, but it's curious to me.
So you begin each of your Call Me Back episodes with a timestamp.
DAN SENOR: Yeah. And -
FRANK BLAKE: You have a time in New York, and you have a time in
Tel Aviv.
DAN SENOR: Yeah.
FRANK BLAKE: I find that interesting. Why do you do that?
DAN SENOR: The reason we started doing it is because soon after
October 7th, we were doing like three or four episodes a week because news was
happening so quickly.
And we were bringing on our guests, our cast, our ensemble, you know, of, of
guests to come on to react often, or analyze or make sense of news
developments.
And the problem is, is because the news was moving so quickly during those
early months, often I was concerned that if we had a conversation, and we
often, as you know, you have a podcast, so we will record a conversation at one
hour, but we won't post, post it for hours later.
Our, our, our podcast was initially not intended for an Israeli audience.
It was intended for an audience outside of Israel.
What we soon discovered is we've developed a massive audience
inside Israel.
So we're one of the, we have one of the largest audience podcasts among
podcasts for Israelis.
And a lot of Israelis were complaining, you know, you release episodes on a US
schedule, so we don't get to listen to the episode on our morning commute.
So that's why we always release episodes at midnight.
So, like for instance, last night we released a episode at midnight, and then
it's 7:00 AM in Israel.So, we have this gap between when we record the episode and when we release
it.
And often news would happen during that gap.
News would happen from when we, when we finish, recording and when we post it.
And if news had happened, we didn't want our listeners to say,
well, what, wait a minute, they're, they're, they're talking about X, but Y has
happened. Why wouldn't they talk about Y?
And so we by time stamping it, we're letting our listeners know, don't worry,
we didn't miss talking about whatever's transpired.
We just want you to know when we're recording and dropping this conversation,
so you know that if something happened since you can… So that's why we started
it.
Now, since October 7th, or sorry, since those early months, the news has slowed
down a bit.
Not entirely, but it's slowed down a bit.
So we don't really need to do the timestamp anymore.
I don't, but then with certain episodes where we didn't do the timestamp, our
listeners would reach out to us and say, what do you mean no, timestamp?
They, like, for some reason, people love the timestamp.
That's, I don't know why they find it like a, i, I don't know, it's like a
calming thing or something.
FRANK BLAKE: Oh, I think it's very much like an Edward R. Murrow
from London.
Here's where we are.
DAN SENOR: Right.
FRANK BLAKE: A place, it's, it makes it very tangible.
DAN SENOR: Okay. All right. Well, there you go. Yeah.
In fact I'm doing this special series now to reflect on the one year
anniversary.
And for that, those are, those are long form, very long form, like over an hour
conversations that we intend to you know, hopefully live for a long time.
And so they're bigger picture, they're not focused on the news at all.
And so for those, we're not timestamping it, but we're putting those on
YouTube.
They're video interviews, but otherwise, listeners should know we're not giving
up the timestamp.
FRANK BLAKE: Have you been surprised by, I'll call it the arc of
the response here in America since October 7th, where we could, not ended, but
where we could recently have an American hostage shot with really remarkably
little reaction here?
DAN SENOR: It's one of the most depressing things to me about this
past year. there's a lot of things to be depressed about, so there's a lot to
choose from.
But it's about, you know, if you think about the, the hostage crisis in Iran in
the, in 1980, in the last year of the, of the, of the Carter administration,
you know, the idea of Americans being held abroad was being covered literally
every single day.
Nightline with Ted Koppel, that show was started to just cover day-to-day.
The idea that there are American hostages being held somewhere.
You look at the Britney Griner hostage taking more recently in Russia or Evan,
the journalist with the Wall Street Journal, who was held hostage, I mean, in
prison, but really held hostage.
Everyone over here was fixated on it. Everyone knew who these
people were.
Brittany Griner became a household name.
There was a sense of a national cause around it, national American cause.
And the idea that American Jews being held in the dungeons of Gaza are somehow
held to a different standard, is shocking to a degree, but also very revealing
of this moment which we can get into.
But I, yeah, it's just amazing to me.
I mean, if I know for, take Hersh Goldberg-Polin,
for instance, who was just executed a little over two weeks ago I know his
parents I know the family.
They are, I've had them on the podcast.
I had them, last spring when the video was released of Hersch.
And they came on my podcast to talk about it.
They are the most American people you could imagine. I mean, really, for some
reason they don't count.
And I think that's illustrative of a, of a deeper something much deeper going
on here.
That, that Jews are generally just held to a different standard.
FRANK BLAKE: And are there things that, I mean, as you've looked
over the past year, first, it is amazing, there's been almost a year as you, as
you look, is there, is there a knowledge base or ignorance with the American
people that's been surprising?
I mean, do you go, I wish they knew more about this, or I wish they took the
time to know more about this?
Or do you think it's sort of a willful ignorance?
DAN SENOR: One would be that the Jews have been in Israel and the
land of Israel for thousands of years.
The Jews didn't just show up in 1948, or in the years preceding the founding of
the state, the Jews have so - so this idea that the Jews were somehow, you
know, colonialists or representatives of colonialists or whatever the, the
narrative is, just any basic understanding of Jewish history, of history,
period, gives lie to that, canard.
Second is, I wish Americans could understand that Israel left Gaza in 2005.
Israel left Gaza.
I feel like I have to say that over and over Israel left Gaza.
The idea that that the massacre of October 7th was in any way, a legitimate or
quasi legitimate response to an occupation is, again, belied by just basic
history.
Israel left Gaza in 2005.
Hamas took over in Gaza after Israel was gone in 2006, and decided that instead
of building what Israel had left, which as many envisioned could have been like
a Singapore on the, on the Mediterranean, it's a beau - I've been to Gaza, by
the way.
It's a beautiful strip of land. Beautiful. And it, could be an extraordinary
asset.
And Israel left behind when it, when it left Gaza in 2005, when it, when it had
its own military, go door to door in Israeli settlements in Gaza, and forcibly
remove its own citizens from their homes.
They left behind homes and greenhouses. And they were all lit on fire and
burned by, by Hamas, by Palestinians after Israel was gone.
So Israel's gone. So, so this idea that Israel is responding, that the massacre
of October 7th was some kind of response to an Israeli presence is absurd.
And the same goes for the North Israel, left Southern Lebanon,
1999, 2000 Israel's out of there.
So Hezbollah's in Southern Israel, Southern Lebanon, Israel is not, so, what is
the basis for the Hezbollah attacks, constant barrage of attacks against
Israel?
There's no, there's no territorial dispute. There's no, so, so what?
So, so that's the idea that these, these attacks against Israel are somehow a
response to Israel's presence in these places is not true.
And the third thing I wish Americans understood, and this is
probably the most important, is too many people tend to think of the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict as the conflict.
And the reality is it's just one front in a much bigger conflict.
And that much bigger conflict is Iran's ambition to annihilate the state of
Israel, which they've said quite explicitly that that is their intention.
They have an annihilation strategy.
I think they're going to pursue that strategy more robustly.
Now in the post-October 7th World, and they have a number of
fronts from which to squeeze Israel.
There's Hezbollah in the north, there's the Houthis, there's Syria, there's
some radicalized Palestinian groups in the West Bank, and there's Hamas or what
was left, what is left of Hamas in the South.
And then there's obviously Iran's own capabilities, which could become nuclear
capabilities very soon.
Their intention is to squeeze Israel from every direction.
I think there's currently a seven-front war against Israel, and it's all being
orchestrated by Tehran.
And to fixate on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is to fixate on just one
front of a much bigger war.
It would be Matti Friedman, who's a very thoughtful Israeli journalist and
observer of Israeli events, who lives in Jerusalem, who I've had on my podcast
twice, three, twice actually recording him again soon.
He, you know, he makes this point that to talk about the Israeli Palestinian
conflict would be like during World War II, or looking back at World War II,
we'd talk about, you know, America's, the Allies' war with Italy.
Like what war with Italy? What do you, what do you mean the war?
It wasn't, it was a world, yes, but there was this war with Italy, but to, to
focus on America's war, the west's war with Italy during World War II is to
actually believe it was an isolated event that was worthy of understanding in
its own isolated way.
But of course, you can't understand the West's war with Italy or the Allies'
war with Italy without understanding where it fit into the broader world,
second World War.
And I would say to understand the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is to understand
Iran's war against Israel.
And once you understand what Israel's up against you wonder why Israel hasn't
taken even a stronger position against Hamas.
FRANK BLAKE: Right. Those are three brilliant, brilliant points.
Shifting gears some, because your show is also very effective in identifying
some of the stresses within Israeli society, very logically and emotionally
powerful ways, just given the horror and the attacks they're facing.
And you have a really interesting view of Israel's and Israeli resilience and
how that comes about.
Do you want to discuss that a bit?
DAN SENOR: I co-authored a book with the same gentleman I
co-authored "Startup Nation" with named Saul Singer, who's my, who lives in
Jerusalem.
He's my brother-in-law, actually. And we're very close friends in addition to
being family.
And we wrote a book called "The Genius of Israel," and the subtitle is "The
Surprising Resilience of a Divided Nation in a Turbulent World."
And we wrote this book before October 7th. We wrote this book, not anticipating
October 7th, but of course, it's become as relevant in the post-October.
The book was published on November 1st, which is, you know, means that we had
to write it well before October 7th.
We wrote it and, and, and is like many, including the New York Times book
review of all places, which I normally don't count on for a fair review, said
that the book, the "Genius of Israel" to come out after October 7th, is, you
know, a year which Israel has had a very tumultuous year, not just October 7th,
but the divisive debates inside Israel over judicial reform, which dominated
much of 2023 for Israel, to have a book called "The Genius of Israel" seems
like the worst possible title, worst time title.
And he says, and yet the reviewer said in the Times, he says, yet, if Israel
manages to dig out of this major setback, this book will explain how they did
it.
Because it's a book that explains why Israelis are so resilient.
Now, I'm not gonna go through all the factors.
Hopefully your listeners will buy the book.
FRANK BLAKE: Yeah.
DAN SENOR: But I will say a few things.
One, it is a country that prioritizes service and public service among above,
most everything else.
So the, you know, average Israeli, not all, but most Israelis at formative
periods of their lives serve in the military - ages, you know, males for three
years, females for two years, unless they go on to serving an officer, you
know, do officer training, or they serve in an elite unit or, or they get
called up for reserves like they, many of them are now, but they basically
serve for a few years.
And it's definitional in Israeli life.
I mean, your connection to Israeli society, your status in Israeli society, is
very much your reputation in Israeli society is largely driven by your military
service.
And what that does, Frank, is it, is it puts, it puts a sense of, country above
self, meaning there's a sense that, some things are larger and more important
than just, just me.
Me being part of something larger, a family, a community, and a
country is, is the priority.
That's very important when a country faces a setback.
When a country faces a setback, that individuals feel connected to that
country, to the point that they're willing to put their life on the line, on
the lines for that country. A.
And, and by the way, the sense of service begins before military service.
If you look at every stage of Israeli life, which we show in our book, Israeli
youth from every stage of their life, are raised with this sense of national
and communal purpose.
Two, the role of ritual in Israeli life.
And it's everything from religious ritual.
So we have a chapter in the book called Thanksgiving Every Week where we say,
we argue that Israel has its equivalent of an American Thanksgiving every
Friday night.
Most of the country shuts down.
Families are together every Friday night for the Sabbath, often multiple
generations.
And they, and, and they just, families stay connected to each other.
And again, that sense of, I'm part of something larger than just myself, my own
life, my own success, my own material gain.
I'm connected to a multi-generational experience.
I'm connected to a family and a and a people, and a country that has this long
history that I can help shape.
And then even non-religious rituals.
So Israel's, we write a lot about in the book about Israel's Independence Day
and Israel's Memorial Day.
I'm always struck when Israelis come to the U.S. if they're here, friends of
mine, and they're here around our Memorial Day, and they're perplexed when they
hear things like, what on earth is a Memorial Day sale?
Like, what's, like, they, they see these advertise memorial, they're like
memorial, isn't it Memorial Day to honor people who've given their lives for
the country, and it's now a sale and a barbecues, and, you know, and so in
Israel, Memorial Day is, first of all, they, they have Memorial Day and
Independence Day back to back.
So, so they're one day apart.
So the idea is you go through the loads of Memorial Day where you're honoring
people whose lives have been lost.
And you go right into Independence Day, which is celebratory, but it's because
it's against the backdrop of Memorial Day.
Independence Day means something, meaning people understand we don't get this,
the independence and freedom without that, which is sacrifice, people
sacrificing their lives and the whole country.
If, if your listeners haven't been there, I, I always tell people, if you, if
you're going to Israel for the first time, if you can, time it try to go on is Israel's
Memorial Day, or be there around then, because what you see is on Memorial Day,
there's a siren that goes off across the country, an air raid siren, and for
two minutes, approximately that siren bellows, and the whole country stops.
People, cars on highways stop.
People get out of their cars and stand in silence together. People leave office
buildings, university classes, schools, restaurants, whatever.
Everyone stops for two minutes.
And in that two minutes, of course, they're, they're remembering their
individual loss, but there's also a collective experience where they're, where
they're, where they're remembering those who put their lives above all else for
the country.
And the fact that all Israelis share in that experience is, is so, so I just
think ritual is so important to, to resilience.
I think if you, if you teach young people that service is important, and some
things are more important, important than their own individual ambition, if you
ground them with a sense of religious ritual, communal ritual, and, and then a
sort of national ritual that ties them to their history and ties them to the
country's future, you add all these things up and others we write about, it
gives people resilience.
They have shock absorbers on how to like bounce back from setbacks.
FRANK BLAKE: So I, there are two quotes that stick with me from your book, which we are gonna give away to our listeners.
You talk about the optimism within the country,
and there's one, there are two great phrases.
One was you quote someone as saying, it's not about being optimistic that
things will work out.
It's about being optimistic about what happens when they don't.
DAN SENOR: Right.
FRANK BLAKE: Does that survive this event?
DAN SENOR: So obviously, I hate to make a full throw of prediction
in real time during a real time crisis.
It's a great question, but I think, yes.
And, and the, what I'm basing that on so far is, well, first of all, while I
said that, Israel has, this is the, the worst event and the most historic
event, tragically in the history of the Jewish people in the history of Israel,
in my lifetime Israel has experienced major setbacks.
And the, and the period I look to and point to that I think is most
illustrative of this is the 1970s.
In 1972, you know, there was the massacre at the Munich Olympics where Israelis
were slaughtered by a Palestinian terror group in Munich, 1973, Israel's
completely caught off guard by the Yom Kippur war, by the attacks from Egypt
and Syria and others.
And, and this was after Israelis were feeling triumphant from the
1967, six day war, 1974, you had Maalot, which is a town up in Northern Israel,
where there was a terrorist group that had come into Israel from, from southern
Lebanon, and took over an Israeli school, massacred a massive number of, of
Israeli children.
It was quite brutal.
These are all massive setbacks, by the way.
But 1974 was also peak period for the Soviet Union, basically declaring any Jew
in the Soviet Union that wanted to leave to go to Israel was gonna lead a
miserable life trapped in the Soviet Union.
There was a policy, that was implemented. 1975, the United Nations General
Assembly passes a resolution defining Zionism as a racist.
Okay, so I just described to you 1972, 1975, any one of those events would be
tragic.
1976, by the way, I can keep going.
1976, you had the Entebbe terrorist operation in Uganda, which,
which were Jews were separated from non-Jews, and they just assumed they were
all gonna be slaughtered.
Fortunately, there was this heroic rescue, 1976, and then, so this was like a
very dark period, '72 to '76.
And then 1977, Anwar Sadat, the president of Egypt, flies to Israel, goes to
Jerusalem, goes before the Knesset Israel's parliament, and says, I want peace
with Israel.
I want, you know, mutual recognition. I recognize Israel's right to exist.
And basically, within two years, there was a peace treaty, a formal peace
treaty between Israel and Egypt, which for all its flaws and complications is
still held.
And, and then, you know, obviously it's not to say that Israel hasn't had
setbacks after that.
I don't think you could imagine such a stunning turnaround from such despair in
the first part of that decade.
And then, you know, the possibilities of normalization, at least
with one of Israel's longest standing, largest, most powerful enemies in the
end of that decade.
And so I think things can turn around and they can turn around, you know, in
unexpected ways relatively quickly.
And I think a, a big reason they can, and they will in Israel's
case, is because Israelis, despite the despair right now about the length of
the war, despite the degree to which Israel's not equipped for fighting this
kind of war, though it's learning to meaning the length of the war which
Israelis are not.
You know, this is the longest war Israel's fought since Israel's War of
Independence.
They, and then despite the, the tense debates inside Israel about how Israel
navigates going forward this war, Israelis are still committed.
There aren't reservists who are refusing to serve Israelis are still in net
numbers returning to Israel, not leaving Israel.
Sure, there are some Israelis that are leaving Israel, but they're
statistically insignificant.
The more interesting thing is, I mean, Israel's population, it's literally,
it's population grew something by like 7 or 8% in October of 2023.
Meaning while the massacre was happening in the immediate aftermath of the
massacre, Israelis living abroad or traveling abroad were fighting to get plane
seats back to Israel.
They weren't like, wow, phew. I dodged a bullet literally and metaphorically, I
dodged a bullet.
I wasn't in Israel when this happened. And I'm, I'm, I'm working at Intel in,
in the Bay Area. I'm working at, or I'm traveling in Asia.
Oh, thank God I missed that, and I'll just return when things calm down.
No, they were, they were, they were doing everything they can, everything they
could to get on planes back to Israel.
And so I think Israel's the only country in the modern history that whose
population grew during wartime rather than shrunk.
And so, or at least maintained the same size.
And so I, I think all this, what all this speaks to is Israelis are not giving
up on their country.
And, and so I remain cautiously optimistic.
We have a whole chapter in the book about, about just the fact that Israelis,
even secular Israelis are having so many children, is is illustrative of, of a,
of a dynamic forward-looking optimistic country.
So it's a country with a high fertility rate.
It's got the highest density of technology startups in the world outside of
Silicon Valley.
It, it's got over 400 multinational companies with innovation centers and
R&D centers in Israel.
And those R&D and innovation centers are not closing.
These are multinationals from all over the world, and despite all the stress in
Israel, they're not shutting down.
And it is a country where people still feel connected to each other and to the
country as, as articulated by these rituals I just talked about and expressed.
And in other ways too. I wouldn't bet against a country with those dynamics.
I wouldn't bet against the country with those dynamics anytime, especially
while it's facing a seven front war, and those dynamics are still at play, I
would put that country against any other country any day of the week.
So I, so I guess I'm rounding out by saying I'm, yeah, I'm optimistic.
FRANK BLAKE: Yeah.
And the other point in your book and this is now asking you to reflect on the
implications here in the United States is you say, Israel, one of the sources
of optimism is Israel's a country built on a story.
As is the United States.
What should the United States, what should Americans be learning from this?
DAN SENOR: From the Israeli story?
FRANK BLAKE: Yeah, yeah.
DAN SENOR: Look, it's, it's a story about a people that have been in a land for
thousands of years, despite multiple empires trying to drive them, and
sometimes successfully for periods of time out of, out of the land.
And a persistence to stay in the land, return to the land, and build a modern
free liberal small-L liberal society that is, you know, open and dynamic and
democratic and is a society that is not only a model for the world, because
it's an island in the sea of chaos, meaning the region and, and still manages
to thrive in all the ways I just described.
But it's also making a real contribution to the world through all its
innovation when life sciences and dealing with climate challenges and, and
dealing with security challenges and dealing with, I mean, I can go on and on
and on, the way Israel is, helping the world become a better place.
And, and it is, it is like this mix of, it's a blend.
It's a balance between a sense of rootedness to history, community and family,
and, and sort of forward looking this of how can we be a dynamic modern country
in a, in a fast changing world.
And that it has struck this balance between the two is really is Israel's
story.
FRANK BLAKE: Last question.
I ask this to everybody we have on the podcast, and, again, I thank you for
what you're doing on your podcast.
Because I think that's a crazy good turn. Who has done a crazy good turn for you in your life?
Who's done something really kind, really important, had a big impact on your
life?
DAN SENOR: I guess, and this is gonna be a cliche, but I'll, I'll
say it nonetheless.
My mother, Helen Senor, who is a who's had massive disruption in her life at
every stage of her life.
She's the child was a hidden child during the Holocaust. She's from Slovakia.
She's a survivor of the Holocaust. She was on the run as a little kid.
She was saved by, her life was saved by what we call a righteous Gentile, a
non-Jew who risked his own life to protect the lives of Jews.
And then she moved to North America as a young girl, had a very difficult time
as an immigrant.
Ultimately got married, had children, lost her husband, too early, early, too
young, my father. She was a widow.
In her 70s, she made the decision to make Aliyah to move to Israel in the middle of the 2014 Israel, Gaza War, Israel Hamas war, despite us trying to discourage her from moving at that time.
I would just say, I can go on and on at every stage of her life.
She's, she's dealt with major, major challenges and adversity.
And, she kind of keeps all in stride, never panics, never gets hysterical,
stays calm.
She is almost, to me like a walking… she embodies the Jewish story, the Israeli
story of how do you, she's a religious woman.
She takes her Judaism very seriously in terms of, I think that's a part of her
calm, that's part of her connection to a larger story, to your earlier
question.
And, in so doing, she's become a role model for me. Because I deal with a lot
of crazy, unpredictable events.
I try to make sense of major volatility in the world.
And I just, I think I have some calm in the midst of it all because of her
model to me and her role modeling to me without even intending, just, just the
way, by the way, she's lived her life.
FRANK BLAKE: That is brilliant.
This whole conversation has been exceptional. Thank you again, Dan, for what you're doing.
I just urge all our listeners to listen to your podcast. We're going to give
away your book.
This is important at an incredibly important time in the history of not only
the United States and Israel, but also I think the whole world.
So thank you.
DAN SENOR: Thanks so much, Frank. Really appreciate it.
Enter to win a FREE copy of ‘The Genius of Israel’
In his newest book, "The Genius of Israel: The Surprising Resilience of a Divided Nation in a Turbulent World," best-selling author and foreign policy expert Dan Senor tells the story of a society built around the values of service, solidarity, and belonging - and what other people and countries can learn from it.
To celebrate his appearance on the show, we're giving away 40 FREE copies of Dan's book, "The Genius of Israel."
Click here to sign up for your chance to win.
From Frank Blake
My Sincere Thanks
Your support has helped take our little idea to celebrate generosity and good deeds, and turn it into one of the most listened-to podcasts available.
Thank you for being part of a community that celebrates people who do good things for others.
Your giving of your time to listen to these interviews, and acknowledging those good deeds, is a crazy good turn of its own.
Please help us continue to grow by subscribing on your preferred podcast platform.
And please, help us spread the word by sharing our show and website with friends.